Given that aspiring performers spend so much time practicing alone, though, are most acquiring expert collaborative skills? And are music schools teaching smart collaborative practices?
Frankly, I have my doubts.
Acquiring Collaborative Skills
Needless to say, we build up collaborative abilities by actually working in groups. But let’s face it, for students, it’s often a tangled process in which dysfunction scuttles achievement, particularly when artistic opinions clash.
Although music colleges provide students with opportunities to collaborate, I get the impression that most budding collaborators undergo trial by fire – genuine training in the mainstays of collaboration is haphazard and reactive.
A student quartet, for example, might receive pointers for dealing with disagreements, but not until they’re about to implode.
Some young performers study with teachers who emphasize team skills, but I believe that all musicians would gain more facility as collaborators if music curricula would better integrate instruction in collaborative topics.
Egalitarian vs. Leader-run Groups
Before we go any further, let’s differentiate between two basic types of musical groups: egalitarian and leader-run.
Some ensembles merge aspects of both types, for instance, The Modern Jazz Quartet, in which John Lewis was the artistic director yet the musicians contributed more or less equally in performances.
For our purposes here, though, I’ll treat the two sorts of groups as distinct.
Most young musicians get plenty of experience performing in leader-run ensembles; they arrive at college knowing how to function in the likes of choirs, orchestras, and concert bands.
Furthermore, the ground rules in such ensembles are relatively straightforward – performers have little responsibility beyond preparing their parts, showing up, and behaving.
Still, there are issues of protocol in leader-run groups that fly beneath the radar of many students, so I highlight key concerns in Chapter 6 of my book The Musician’s Way.
Nonetheless, that chapter, titled “Musical Collaboration,” primarily focuses on egalitarian groups (e.g., string quartets, jazz combos, rock bands) because musicians working in these sorts of ensembles encounter profound challenges.
And students’ experiences in leader-run groups seldom prepare them to handle the intricacies they face when they collaborate in self-governing partnerships.
The Keys to Creative Collaboration
In egalitarian ensembles, musicians must make shared decisions about repertoire, interpretation, rehearsing, concert presentation, and so forth. Inevitably, opinions diverge, and compromises need to be made, often in a hurry.
In the end, a group’s success will rest on three things apart from each musician’s artistic and technical abilities:
- The group’s culture
- The members’ interpersonal skills
- The ensemble’s rehearsal and performance strategies
In Chapter 6, therefore, I zero in on those three subjects.
To summarize, an effective group culture begins with professionalism. In The Musician’s Way, I distill professional conduct into four elements – punctuality, preparation, courtesy, & integrity – and I discuss each one in turn. (Update: see “The 4 Pillars of Professionalism.”)
I then delve into interpersonal skills by highlighting a number of rehearsal situations that egalitarian groups face, such as how members can resolve interpretive differences and handle criticism, and I illustrate ways in which musicians can achieve consensus, criticize constructively, and more.
Next, two sections outline a range of rehearsal and performance strategies.
I round out the chapter with guidelines for forming a group. Central to that discussion is a list of 12 questions that musicians should ask themselves and each other before they decide to team up – see “12 Questions for Prospective Bandmates.”
In total, The Musician’s Way incorporates vastly more information about collaboration than I and my peers ever received during our music educations. I hope that it will empower today’s rising musicians to become adept collaborative artists.
© 2009 Gerald Klickstein