“The road to improvement is paved with evaluations.”
The Musician’s Way, p. 296
Whatever our level of artistic development, we’re always aiming to grow.
And one of the primary ways that we advance is through critiques because other viewpoints alert us to our blind spots.
So, the more adept we become at handling criticism, the better our creative work is likely to be.
Here’s a 3-step process I employ that empowers me and my students to derive maximum benefit from criticism.
Three Steps to Benefit from Criticism
1. Seek Out Critiques
With any creative project that I undertake, I assume that I could be missing something in my concept or execution.
For those reason, I ask colleagues to evaluate my writing, my playing, and my ideas.
I not only solicit feedback from those close to me but also from people that I don’t know well, thereby accessing unfamiliar perspectives.
2. Listen Objectively
When a critique runs contrary to our expectations, it can be difficult for us to hear criticism accurately. And if the people from whom we request advice sense that we won’t welcome their thoughts, they’ll be less likely to speak honestly.
To open myself to critiques and encourage frankness from those I consult, I treat criticism as impersonal information. I defer judgment and take in the criticism with a detached attitude.
I also use active listening strategies:
- I paraphrase to ensure that I’ve heard correctly
- I show enthusiasm for alternate opinions instead of taking a defensive stance
- I invite views that are beyond my experience
“Defer judgment and take in the criticism with a detached attitude.”
3. Respond Constructively
I deem sincere criticism to be a gift, so I thank those who evaluate my work irrespective of whether the criticism I receive is tactful or proves productive.
Also, if I don’t understand someone’s outlook, I ask for clarification using an upbeat emotional tone so that my questioning won’t carry a whiff of counter-criticism.
Even if an assessment runs contrary to my sensibilities, I appreciate it and invite additional feedback because I know that considering opposing views can lead me to unexpected discoveries.
I then apply what I learn, and, in doing so, produce better work than I would have otherwise.
Detailed guidelines for handling criticism can be found in The Musician’s Way under “Interacting in Rehearsal” (p. 117-121) and “Appreciating Criticism” (p. 296-299).
Embracing the unknown
Self-evaluation: The key to artful practice
The self-motivated musician
© 2011 Gerald Klickstein
Photo licensed from Shutterstock.com
You’re most welcome, TK. Thanks for the lively comment.
I’m so glad I came upon your blog!
This is an excellent post regarding criticism. Us “creative types” seem to have a difficult time accepting criticism because what we do is so personal, as it comes from our souls. I like what you said about “I defer judgment and take in the criticism with a detached attitude.”
If we don’t accept constructive criticism, we will fail to grow. It might be hard to hear, but in the long run we will be grateful. Thank you for this post!
Thanks, Alexandra – great to hear from you.
can’t find anything to criticise about the comment; well-stated.